Mother of girl operated on by disgraced surgeon says hospital 'gaslit' her

The mother of a young girl operated on by a disgraced surgeon at a famous London children's hospital said she should never have been left in his care.

Jodee Seeley told BBC Newsnight she was considering legal action after Great Ormond Street Hospital (Gosh), whom she accuses of "gaslighting" her, allowed Yaser Jabbar to operate on her daughter Alana even when complaints had been raised about his misconduct.

Mr Jabbar left the hospital in 2023 after a Royal College of Surgeons inquiry found he had performed "incorrect" or "inappropriate" surgery in several cases.

A spokesperson for Gosh said it understood "why Alana and her family are worried" and apologised that "they feel information was withheld from them".

Mr Jabbar had operated on Jodee's daughter in 2022, when she was eight years old, fitting metal plates into her knees for leg lengthening and straightening.

He was a leading surgeon at the renowned hospital, operating on children with complicated disorders and carrying out procedures, such as the one undergone by Alana, who has a complex chromosome abnormality.

The hospital has since initiated independent reports into each of his 723 patients to conclude what level of harm they had experienced.

Some cases linked to Mr Jabbar resulted in harm, including life-long injuries and amputation.

Jodee, from Essex, told the BBC's Newsnight programme that she had no idea of the doctor's reputation when her daughter Alana was referred to his care in 2021.

At that point, concerns had already been raised about Mr Jabbar.

She said that at the family's first consultation in March 2021, which lasted "about five minutes", Mr Jabbar had advised the invasive surgery.

"We didn't want to rock the boat too much because he seemed like he knew exactly what he was doing," she said.

"So we kind of went along with it thinking he's an orthopaedic surgeon, it's Great Ormond Street [Hospital]. We trusted him."

She said she was told the surgery would improve Alana's mobility and put her "knee into place... and then from there we could assess whether anything else needed to be done".

The operation took place 10 months later, in January 2022. During that period, more professional complaints from other surgeons were raised with the managers at the hospital.

None of this was ever disclosed to Jodee or other families of Mr Jabbar's patients.

She said the surgery had appeared to go well and, with Alana's leg bandaged up, there had not seemed to be any immediate problems.

But when the bandage came off a few weeks later, Jodee saw two scars instead of one on the inside of her child's leg when they had been told it would be just one incision.

"The alarm bells rang at that point," she said.

As weeks went by, the mobility of Alana, now aged 11, was not improving and she was reporting pain frequently, often needing painkillers.

Jodee said she had thought at first: "Well, maybe it just hasn't worked? Maybe that wasn't the right procedure and it will be removed? Or maybe it's just too early to tell?"

She said she had expected regular check-ups from the hospital but a follow-up appointment did not come until July - six months after the operation.

The plates in Alana's knees were supposed to be there for about two years and Jodee says another surgeon at the hospital recommended keeping the plates in place at the follow-up appointment.

Then, by chance, they saw Mr Jabbar on the same visit.

Jodee said he took one look and said they "needed to come out immediately" and asked the family to return the following day for another major operation.

He told the family he was worried Alana's tendons could re-fuse to the metal plates, Jodee said.

"We were really panicked, we were really worried.... [thinking] 'What have we done, is she okay, is it long-term damage?'"

They returned to the hospital in August 2022 to have the plates removed.

But the family's concern was now so strong that they moved Alana to a different hospital months after.

Jodee said her daughter's mobility was now "worse" and that she was "still having falls".

Jodee said she was not informed of anything wrong with Mr Jabbar's work until February this year, more than 16 months on.

She said the hospital informed her only in a brief letter with few details.

"It seemed like quite a general letter... nothing to worry about," she said.

She did not realise the extent of Mr Jabbar's reported misconduct until media reports.

"I did not realise the scale of it or what actually happened or that there had been so many complaints," she added.

"I just felt sick, to be honest," she said. "So obviously devastated. As a parent, obviously you want to protect your child, it is the number one priority. And I knew something was amiss when we had seen him."

Jodee said her daughter should never have been put under the surgeon's care and has accused the hospital of a culture of complicity.

She told the BBC she had heard from the hospital immediately prior to talking to reporters.

She said this could be a coincidence or "they've been pushed to do that because they were aware that I'd be coming to talk to you today".

"It does actually feel like they've been gaslighting the whole way," she added.

Jodee said she and her family were very private but she had felt compelled to speak out so other victims could know they are "not alone".

"It's really important for other people to know what's happened and to understand if they're being gaslighted as well, that they're not alone, that this is what's going on," she said.

A spokesperson for the hospital said it was sorry to all concerned families, adding that after the Royal College of Surgeons report, it had asked external experts to review all Mr Jabbar's patients.

The statement goes on: "They are working at pace [...] We understand why Alana and her family are worried [...] and we have reached out to them.

"We are sorry they feel that information was withheld from them. Once concerns were raised about the surgeon's practice in June 2022, we shared these with the General Medical Council and undertook rapid fact-finding. During this period the surgeon's practice was restricted to simple procedures [...] and always as part of a wider surgical team.

"We then had to establish the facts before sharing information with patients.

"We are now updating patients regularly about the progress of the review.

"We are aware there were concerns regarding specific patients in 2021 that were raised as formal incidents and were fully investigated. The findings in each individual case and collectively did not trigger the threshold for initiating further action at that time."

Great Ormond Street's actions in the wake of Mr Jabbar's departure have continued to come under fire.

This year the hospital has initiated independent reports into each of his 723 patients, to conclude what level of harm they experienced.

But families who have received the results in recent weeks have called the reviews a mis-representation and a "whitewash" of what their children experienced.

Parents have told the BBC how the hospital "failed their children", leaving them physically and mentally damaged.

The BBC has spoken to at least four families - and had indirect contact with 12 more - who say the reports do not reflect their children's experiences or minimise their pain and suffering.

The reviews, carried out by specialist surgeons who did not work at GOSH, were based on patient notes provided by the hospital.

Many of the reports were also made without any interviews with the patient or their family.

Update 19th December: This article has been updated to remove a paragraph about communications between the family and the hospital, in order to clarify that the hospital informed patients and their families about Mr Jabber's reported misconduct before the media.