Who will run a council with no majority?

Dan O'Brien
Senior Political Reporter, Wiltshire
Sophie Parker
BBC News, Wiltshire
BBC Liberal Democrat leader on Wiltshire Council Ian Thorn smiles at the camera in a blue suit jacket and woolly scarf.BBC
Ian Thorn is leader of the Liberal Democrats on Wiltshire Council

The Liberal Democrats say they "intend to lead Wiltshire moving forward", despite not having a majority.

For the first time, the Lib Dems became the biggest party in last week's local elections, but fell short of the 50 seats needed to control the chamber.

The Conservatives say it is premature for the Liberal Democrats to already be forming their cabinet as there is no guarantee of how the new administration will function.

The key Wiltshire Council meeting to appoint a new leader, where any power sharing deals are first tested, takes place on Tuesday 20 May.

The Liberal Democrats in Wiltshire even had a visit from national leader Sir Ed Davey at the weekend after the result - he played cricket with the county's Lib Dem leader, Ian Thorn.

"We won the popular vote. We think it's absolutely right that the Liberal Democrats should lead any administration in Wiltshire going forward," said Mr Thorn.

He is very insistent his party will lead the council and said he does not see discussing a cabinet as premature, but instead wants to show that the party is "determined" and make it clear there is a "first class team to take us forward".

That would appear to include inviting an independent councillor Jon Hubbard to join their ruling cabinet, Mr Thorn suggested on social media.

PA Media Ed Davey fist bumps Ian Thorn (who we can only see the back of) while they are both in cricket kit. They are on a cricket field with trees in the background on a sunny day.PA Media
Sir Ed Davey congratulated Ian Thorn after the election results

Analysis: Dan O'Brien, Wiltshire political reporter

It's an obvious fact that suddenly becomes important - if you want to get something done in a council chamber, you need to persuade the majority of councillors to vote in your favour.

At County Hall, that means persuading at least 50 of the 98 councillors to pick your side. The Liberal Democrats, now the largest party, have 43.

They strongly believe that with the most councillors, and winning the popular vote, they now deserve to run the show - but there are no guarantees for how this will all play out.

They're promising to listen to all sides, but it is hard to envisage the Conservatives or Reform UK's councillors backing too many Lib Dem ideas.

So the way things are heading, they'll push to persuade the independent group and the one remaining Labour councillor to team up - only just getting them over the line.

Whether we see a formal coalition or something less official, we don't yet know - but the Lib Dems have already published their hopes for an independent councillor to take a seat on the cabinet.

It's possible this leads to a more collaborative form of politics and decision making - that's what the Lib Dem leader is hoping for and there are plenty of councils across the land who make this sort of setup work.

But the approach is yet to be tested against Wiltshire's new political reality.

A crowd of people in an atrium, gathering around people sitting at trestle tables counting vote papers
The election count last week was tense as it was became clear that there would be no clear winner

Mr Thorn has reiterated the desire for working collaboratively with other parties.

"I think it's a really good thing that politicians for different parties are being made to work together, which is exactly what's happening here," he said.

But with Reform being elected in 10 seats, Mr Thorn acknowledged there a lot of different political views in the county and the council.

"I think there is clearly a large number of people who are disaffected from party politics and I don't blame them for that," he said.

He added that as the main opposition in the council chamber for a long time, the Lib Dems felt ignored, and he does not want that to happen in the future.

"We've had far too much tribalism," he said.

"The opportunities are there for every adult in the room who wishes to contribute. I want to hear from those people and want to work with them moving forward."

Follow BBC Wiltshire on Facebook, X and Instagram. Send your story ideas to us on email or via WhatsApp on 0800 313 4630.