PM says motorhome migrant fine 'to be looked into'

Lewis Adams
BBC News, Essex
Watch: Migrant emerges from back of motorhome

Prime Minister Sir Keir Starmer said he would ask the Home Office to look into the case of a couple who were fined for unknowingly bringing a migrant into the UK.

The intruder hid inside the cover of a bike rack while Adrian and Joanne Fenton drove from France to their home in Heybridge, Essex, in October.

They have objected to the Home Office after later being fined £1,500 for failing to "check that no clandestine entrant was concealed" in their motorhome.

Speaking during Prime Minister's Questions, Sir Keir said he was "concerned" to hear what had happened to the couple and it was "important" that the case was looked into.

The government authority previously said penalties were "designed to target negligence rather than criminality".

In an email to the Home Office, seen by the BBC, Mr Fenton wrote: "At no point did I believe I would be fined by taking correct and moral action."

The dispute inspired a YouGov poll, which asked more than 4,500 British adults if they thought it was fair that the Fentons had been fined.

A total of 81% of respondents responded it was "unfair".

Joanne Fenton A garage with two people, one of them a police officer, standing above another person sitting on the floor, whose face is blurred.Joanne Fenton
The man, who said he was from Sudan, was zipped inside a bike rack on a motorhome for six hours before being found by Adrian and Joanne Fenton
Steve Hubbard/BBC Adrian and Joanne Fenton wearing coats and standing in front of their navy and white motorhome, which is parked in front of their house. They have serious expressions on their faces.Steve Hubbard/BBC
Adrian and Joanne Fenton say they have lodged an objection to their £1,500 fine

The couple claimed border officials in Calais and the UK had not inspected the bike rack or the cover before or after they crossed via ferry on 15 October.

Their local MP, Maldon Conservative Sir John Whittingdale, addressed the prime minister about the row on Wednesday.

He told the Commons: "They reported it immediately to the police, only to receive a fine from the Border Force.

"Will [the prime minister] agree that my constituent ought to be thanked rather than punished?

"Does he accept this action will send a message to deter anybody from acting responsibly in the future?"

Sir Keir responded that he was aware of the incident, adding: "I am concerned about it.

"I do think it's important that the Home Office look into it, and therefore we will do so and I will make sure [Sir John] is updated."

'Phone the police'

Retired firefighter Mr Fenton, 57, had been at the wheel for the couple's six-hour journey, arriving at home at 22:15 BST.

Speaking to The JVS Show on BBC Three Counties Radio, Mrs Fenton said her husband unzipped the "really tight" cover and saw two trainers, followed by two legs.

Adrian Fenton lifting the bike rack's cover up. It is on the back of the motorhome, which is parked on a driveway. Mr Fenton is wearing a black jacket and is talking.
Adrian Fenton said the couple's alarm systems on the motorhome did not go off, despite the man managing to get into the bike rack

"He's gone 'Jo, you need to phone the police. We've got a stowaway'," she told the programme.

She said the young man told the police he was aged 16 and from Sudan.

The couple were travelling in Australia over Christmas when they received an email from the Home Office, detailing the offence and fine.

The email also said the "entrant" was found by an authorised search officer, despite the couple saying they called the police the night they found him.

The fine referenced asylum and immigration legislation.

Follow Essex news on BBC Sounds, Facebook, Instagram and X.

Related internet links